This website uses its own and third-party cookies. Some of these cookies are used to develop analytical statistics of visits to the webpage, others to manage advertising or even others are necessary for the correct management of the site. If you continue to browse or click in accept we consider you accept the conditions for their use. You can get more information, or learn how to change the settings in our cookies policy?
Versión Española Versión Mexicana Ibercampus English Version Version française Versione italiana

23/8/2019  
    Ibercampus  | Editorial Board | Who we are | Ideology | Contact | Advertising rates | Subscription | RSS RSS
Policies
Inclusion policies
R&D
Employment
Economics
Culture
Green strategies
Health
Society and consumer
Sports
Debates
Interviews
Education
Grants & internships
Training
Trends
Enterprises & CSR
 Enterprises & CSR
ACNUR
AEGON
AIR LIQUIDE
ALCATEL-LUCENT
ALLIANZ
ARCELORMITTAL
ASIFIN
ASSICURAZIONI GENERALI
AXA
BANCO SANTANDER
BASF
BAYER
BBVA
BNP PARIBAS
CARREFOUR
DAIMLER AG
DEUTSCHE BANK
DEUTSCHE BÖRSE
DEUTSCHE TELEKOM
E.ON
ENEL
ENI
FORTIS
FRANCE TÉLÉCOM
GROUPE DANONE
IBERDROLA
INDITEX
ING GROUP
INTESA SANPAOLO
L'ORÉAL
LVMH
MUNICH RE
NOKIA
PHILIPS
RENAULT
REPSOL YPF
RWE
SAINT GOBAIN
SANOFI-AVENTIS
SAP AG
SCHNEIDER ELECTRIC
SIEMENS AG
SOCIÉTÉ GÉNÉRALE
SUEZ
TELECOM ITALIA
TELEFÓNICA
TOTAL S.A.
UNICREDIT
UNILEVER
VINCI
VIVENDI
VOLKSWAGEN

Caste culture

We Are the Replicants


"If the capacity for personal memory does not distinguish us from artificial forms of intelligence, what does?" —This is one of the questions posed by ´Blade Runner 2049´.
Vanity Fea 3/12/2017 Send to a friend
Comparte esta noticia en TwitterFacebookTwitterdel.icio.usYahooRSS
Madelon Sprengnether has commented as follows in the film in her blog 'Minding Memory' (Psychology Today). 
 
Blade Runner challenges our notions of what distinguishes human from technological forms of intelligence, an increasing concern, if not obsession, of our age.
We depend on technology to an extent that no one in my childhood could have foreseen, much less imagined. We rely on, but also fear, the machines that connect us to the internet, search information data bases for us, manage our investment portfolios, keep our calendars, surveil our properties, and spy perhaps, in the middle of the night, on us.
Blade Runner 2049 assumes all of the above, while raising a new and unexpectedly old-fashioned question. If the capacity for personal memory does not distinguish us from artificial forms of intelligence, what does?

As I see it, the question of humanity versus non-humanity is a red herring used by the Sinister Corporations to manipulate both humans and replicants in the film, and by the screenwriter and director to manipulate the audience. The issue is not one of humanity vs. non-humanity, but of mind-control through ideology, using 'humanity' as an empty badge or shibboleth. I comment thus on MS's post:

To all purposes and intents, the film (like the first one) provides us with replicants that we (the audience) cannot but consider human, thus positioning us on their side, rather than on that of the human overlords who keep them as a separate caste and use the term 'human' and its supposed differential quality as a quite arbitrary (as it turns out) and ultimately non-grounded shibboleth, a mere excuse to preserve a caste system through indoctrination and oppression. In that sense, more 'borderline' replicants would be more challenging to the audience, and make for a more eerily uncanny and creepy film, as we (unlike the humans and the replicants themselves) cannot harbor in practical terms any doubts as to their humanity. As I see it, lots of humans have false memories without that making it any the less human, or indeed act like mindless zombies in most questions without ceasing to be human for all that. Or are we humans in fact only partly human, all of the time, or fully human only part of the time? That's even more unsettling. The replicants are among us, or within ourselves!

We also fall in for symbolic shibboleths dividing us between the US and the Them. (Now it comes to my mind that a recent Naci sprout in an imaginary Eastern Republic tried to justify special privileges for their citizens in the name of a gaseous 'Differential Fact', whose only tangible—so to speak— manifestation was the Spoken Shibboleth itself).

That's what we humans do all the time. Until the Replicants learn their lesson, stop wearing their yellow stars, and enter the game of Caste-casting, inventing another shibboleth of their own. It's all a matter of control and resources —and the colonization of the mind. Replicants are admittedly romantically tragic, telegenic, and they give us dreams of electric sheep, but in fact you can make do with real sheep and with the wooly flocks of humans, herded through electronic media. After all, we can pass the Turing Test in reverse quite easily, by acting like a machine—just by acting like a mindless tool, a human robot, replicating the roles that are given us to internalize, and failing to recognize the human behind the social machinery.
   
—oOo—

Other issues Blogs
My definition of narrative
The Joys of Teaching Literature
Reflecting on the Mind
The Prehistoric Origin of Cinema
Narrative Theory and Narratology blog
Intellectuals against ´Evil´
Let them have it?
One Drop of Blood
Indoctrinating young men —and young women too
Long Line of Sevens

Subscribe free to our newsletter
Vanity Fea
My definition of narrative
José Ángel García Landa
We can all be leaders
VIDEOCOMMUTING A NEW ORGANIZATIONAL REALITY THAT POSITIVELY IMPACTS EMPLOYEES
Mar Souto Romero
Financial inclusion
Financial Education For All!
Carlos Trias
Brusselian Lights
European elections (I): which words are more used in the European political manifestos?
Raúl Muriel Carrasco
Humor and Political Communication
Comisión de Arbitraje, Quejas y Deontología (Spain) (3) You can´t be too careful
Felicísimo Valbuena
Want your own blog? Want to be read by universities?
Find out here
Books
The EU "An Obituary"
Startup Cities "Why Only a Few Cities Dominate the Global Startup Scene"
Blockchain Revolution "How the Technology Behind Bitcoin and Cryptocurrency Is Changing the World "
Doughnut Economics "Seven Ways to Think Like a 21st-Century Economist "
The People vs Tech "How the Internet Is Killing Democracy"
Will Big Business Destroy Our Planet?
Theses and dissertations
1 There is no such thing as a Trump strategy for China
Legal Advise | Privacy Policy | Editorial Board | Who we are | Ideology | Contact | Advertising rates | RSS RSS